How we tested this category
Communities cannot be tested like software, so the protocol changes and we would rather say so than pretend otherwise. We join and participate for at least thirty days before writing anything.
We record: how much genuinely useful material exists behind the paywall, how active it actually is rather than how active the sales page claims, whether the person whose name is on it turns up, how much of it is upsell to a higher tier, and what happens when you ask a hard question in public.
There are no blind tests here and no rubric score that would mean much, so this category is written as assessments rather than scored out of 100.
Two things to declare on this page
One. We earn a recurring commission if you sign up to Skool through our link, and it pays better than anything else on this site.
Two. One of the communities we cover is ours. It is labelled as ours everywhere it appears, and you should weigh anything we say about it accordingly.
Which one is yours
- You want to build a community. The platform question, not the community question.
- You want to learn a specific skill. A cohort with a start date beats an open-ended community almost every time.
- You want to stop feeling behind. Honestly, most people in this bucket need to use one tool properly for a month rather than join anything.